2025-03-07

Fat: The Ubiquitous Fuel and Keys to Climber Performance

Nutrition

Climbing

Performance

Fats

Macronutrients

Fat as an Energy Source: A Long-Lasting Fuel

Fat is a constant energy source; our body burns it 24/7 and, most of the time, it is the predominant fuel source, especially for sedentary people. Unlike carbohydrates, which are a quick energy source and can be burned anaerobically, fat has some distinctive characteristics:

  • Exclusive Aerobic Metabolism: Fat can only be metabolized to produce energy in the presence of oxygen.
  • Abundant Source: The human body has an almost unlimited capacity to store fat, with thousands or tens of thousands of calories available. It is stored mainly in adipose tissue (body fat) and to a lesser extent in muscle tissue.
  • Slow and Limited: Despite its abundance, fat metabolism is slower and subject to several "bottlenecks" that limit its use during intense exercise.

Key Limitations in Fat Use During Exercise

Although ideally we would want to maximize this unlimited fuel source during exercise, there are intrinsic limitations:

1. Inefficient Transport:

  • Unlike carbohydrates and proteins (amino acids), which are water-soluble and dissolve easily in the blood, fat is fat-soluble. This means it requires specific transport proteins to bind to and circulate in the bloodstream.
  • There is a limited number of these transport proteins, which can be compared to a public transport system with a finite number of buses. Once these transporters are saturated, fat cannot be delivered to the muscles at a higher rate.
  • Blood flow also plays a role. During intense exercise, blood flow is diverted to active muscles to deliver oxygen, reducing flow to adipose tissue and thus limiting the release of fatty acids into the bloodstream.
  • The body has an adaptation: with endurance training, it can store more fat directly within muscle cells, which helps partially bypass the limitation of transport from adipose tissue during exercise.

2. High Oxygen Demand:

  • Fat is a molecule that virtually lacks oxygen in the parts that are burned for energy. This means it requires about 10% more oxygen to oxidize than a glucose molecule.
  • This higher oxygen demand translates into greater respiratory effort and a feeling of "hardness" in the effort if fat is predominantly metabolized, especially at high intensities.

Fat vs. Carbohydrates for Performance: The Climber's Choice

Carbohydrates remain the most efficient fuel for power production, even when burned aerobically, because they require less oxygen per unit of energy produced. This is vital for climbers who need bursts of power and intermittent high-contraction efforts.

  • Fat Adaptation: The idea of becoming "fat-adapted" (common in ketogenic diets) aims to make the body burn fat more efficiently. However, studies have shown that the better the body becomes at burning fat, the worse it becomes at burning carbohydrates; it's a trade-off. This adaptation leads to a loss of power and eliminates the only energy source that can be burned anaerobically.
  • Focus on Power, Not Slow Endurance: Performance improvements observed in "fat-adapted" athletes usually occur in tests below the aerobic threshold, which do not reflect the need for maximum power in climbing or many athletic disciplines. The goal of a climber is not to "climb for as many hours as possible and feel good," but to climb as hard as possible.

Fat Metabolism Rates

To give an idea of fat-burning potential:

  • Ultra-marathon athletes on very high-fat diets (70% fat) have reached fat oxidation rates of 1.5 to 1.8 grams per minute during exercise.
  • Highly trained individuals can reach 0.7 grams per minute, moderately trained 0.4 g/min, and low-trained people 0.2 g/min.
  • At rest, the rate is about 0.1 grams per minute.

These numbers show that even at their maximum, the amount of fat burned per day is not hundreds of grams, which puts the potential for body fat loss into context.

Dietary Fat: Beyond Fuel

Dietary fat is more complex and varied than just its role as fuel. It is mainly present as triglycerides, compounds of fatty acids of different lengths attached to a glycerol molecule.

  • Types of Fatty Acids:

    • Saturated: No double bonds, straight structure, usually solid at room temperature (e.g., coconut oil). Their role has been "redeemed," but not all are equal (palmitic acid in palm oil can be harmful for LDL).
    • Monounsaturated: One double bond, "bent" structure, usually liquid (e.g., olive oil).
    • Polyunsaturated (PUFAs): Two or more double bonds, more "bends," liquid (e.g., vegetable oils, fish oils).
    • Trans: Can be natural (small amounts in dairy and meat) or artificial (produced by hydrogenation). Artificial trans fats are harmful, increasing LDL ("bad" cholesterol) and decreasing HDL ("good" cholesterol). Their use in products has been significantly reduced.

  • Omega-3s and Omega-6s (PUFAs):

    • These are polyunsaturated fatty acids with important roles in the body's inflammatory and anti-inflammatory pathways and in cell membrane fluidity.
    • Modern diets tend to be very high in omega-6s (from refined vegetable oils like sunflower, canola, etc.) and low in omega-3s (mainly from fatty fish, flax/chia seeds).
    • The goal is to increase omega-3 intake and reduce omega-6s, mainly by limiting processed foods.
    • Vegan Sources: Conversion of ALA (plant omega-3 from flax) to EPA and DHA (the most "useful" omega-3s) is very inefficient (as low as 9%). Vegans and vegetarians are recommended to consider algae-based EPA/DHA supplements.
    • Oxidized Fats: Polyunsaturated fats, especially omega-3s, are more prone to oxidation. Consuming oxidized fats is harmful, but most fats we eat are not oxidized (rancid fats have an unpleasant smell and taste that serves as a warning).

  • Medium Chain Triglycerides (MCTs):

    • Shorter and can cross the mitochondrial membrane more easily to be burned.
    • Myth: The idea that they are a superior fuel for exercise or weight loss is not supported by evidence at realistic doses. Very high doses of specific types not common in the diet are required. They also share the same blood transport limitations as other fats and can cause gastrointestinal discomfort.
    • "Bulletproof Coffee": While it may reduce calorie intake by replacing a denser breakfast, consuming fat does not stimulate body fat oxidation. The perceived benefit of "burning more fat" or "weight loss" is due to overall calorie restriction, not the fat itself.

  • Cholesterol:

    • An essential waxy molecule, 85% produced by the liver. It is a precursor of steroid hormones (cortisol, testosterone, estrogen) and vitamin D.
    • There is no direct connection between dietary cholesterol and blood cholesterol levels for most people.
    • LDL and HDL: Lipoproteins that transport cholesterol and fats. Oxidized LDL is what contributes to atherosclerosis.
    • A diet rich in fresh, whole foods improves the body's antioxidant capacity, helping prevent LDL oxidation. Diet quality, not a low-fat diet, can make LDL particles "large and buoyant," less prone to oxidation, and contribute to heart health.

Conclusions and Practical Application for Climbers

Fat is a fundamental part of the diet and provides constant energy, but it is not the main source for the explosive power often required by climbers.

  1. Prioritize Whole Sources: Get your fats from whole, fresh foods (avocados, nuts, seeds, olive oil, fatty fish) instead of refined oils or fats added to processed foods.

  2. Don’t Obsess Over Fat Calories: Fat is very energy-dense. Let fat integrate naturally into your diet; you’ll likely meet your needs without overdoing it. Meals with natural fats are very satiating.

  3. Use Added Fat in Moderation: Butter, extra oils in cooking or restaurants add many calories with little nutrition. Use them for pleasure and flavor, but don’t expect major nutritional benefits.

  4. Macronutrient Periodization: On low-activity days, you can opt for a meal with more fat and fewer carbs, and vice versa on high-activity days. The key is overall calorie balance.

  5. Adjust Carbs, Keep Fat Consistent: For many athletes, fat intake can remain relatively constant day to day, while carbohydrates are adjusted significantly according to activity and training level.

  6. Fat Supplements (Caution):

    • L-carnitine supplements have not been shown to significantly increase fat-burning capacity for performance.
    • "Fat burners" (mainly caffeine) only minimally increase fat metabolism and are generally not worth it compared to better dietary management.
    • For vegans and vegetarians, an algae-based omega-3 EPA/DHA supplement is a solid recommendation due to the low conversion from plant sources.

  7. “Real Food” is Key: The basis of optimal nutrition for climbers comes down to eating whole, unprocessed foods in their natural form. This is not "pseudo-naturalist science," but a scientifically backed strategy: whole foods are less calorie-dense, more satiating, and richer in nutrients.

In summary, there are no magic tricks with fat. Maximizing your climbing performance involves a balanced nutritional strategy where fat is consumed intelligently and consciously, prioritizing quality and proper distribution.

Go back to blog